The second weekend of the 2017 6 Nations is over, and I think it is fair to say that this year is on course to be one of the most exciting 6 Nations in history. After Ireland running rampant in Italy, England narrowly beat Wales in Cardiff by scoring a converted try in the last 4 minutes, and France narrowly beat Scotland in Paris. It seems that 5 of the 6 nations are pretty evenly matched, so most of the games look like they could be very close.
Italy v Ireland
Ireland went to Rome seeking to make amends for their loss last week to Scotland. They won comfortably by 63 points to 10, running in 9 tries. Italy were woeful, not to take anything away from Ireland, and it has re-opened the debate as to whether Italy deserve to be in the 6 Nations at all. An idea which has been floating around for a while is that there should be relegation from the 6 Nations, with the second tier European countries like Romania and Georgia in a play-off against the bottom placed country in the 6 Nations table to see who should make up the sixth place the following year.
But, one needs to bear in mind that, when France joined the then 4 Nations to make the 5 Nations (back in 1910) they barely won any matches for well over a decade. Their initial record in the 5 Nations was worse that Italy’s current record in the 6 Nations, but they went on to be one of the best teams in the world. So, in my opinion we should give Italy more time to bring their rugby up to speed, not expel them yet.
Wales v England
This was, for most people, the big game of the weekend. Wales and England have been playing each other since 1881, and had played each other a total of 129 times prior to this weekend. With the record at 60 wins to England, 57 to Wales and 12 drawn matches, long-term they could not be more evenly matched.
It was a cracking match; at no point were the two sides more than 5 points apart, and the ferocity and competitiveness on display was something to behold. This was the best Welsh performance since beating England in the world cup in September 2014. And, it is a match that Wales could have won and should have won. At half time we were 13-8 up, and between 50 and 75 minutes we were, in my opinion, by far the better side. England looked rattled, and at 74 minutes the score was 16-14 to Wales.
With England threatening the Welsh try line, Dan Biggar made a superb interception and broke up field. Isolated, he kicked ahead and a desparate English defence kicked it into touch, giving Wales an attacking line-out in the English 22. But, we fluffed it, and this for me was the incident which lost us the match. With only 5 minutes on the clock, we could have won the line-out, and played out the remaining 5 minutes in England’s 22, or even gone for a drop goal.
But, instead, we found ourselves back under pressure near our own try line. The ball came back to centre Jonathan Davies, who kicked up-field. But, rather than kicking into touch, he kicked in-field, something the Welsh team had been doing all afternoon. It was a crazy decision; he should have belted it into the stands and given the Welsh forwards as much time as possible to slow the game down and regain their breath for the line-out. Instead, George Ford caught Davies’ in-field kick, passed it to Owen Farrell who spun a long pass to winger Elliot Daly. Daly outclassed a poor Alex Cuthbert to score in the corner, and Farrell slotted the conversion to rub salt into the wound.
We went from being in control and 16-14 ahead to losing 21-16.
Wales lost to England 21-16 in Cardiff, with England snatching a try with only 4 minutes left on the clock to break Welsh hearts.
As I say, in my opinion not only were Wales the better team, but it is a match that we lost rather than England winning it. Poor decision making, particularly in the last 5 minutes, cost us what would have been a memorable win over a very good England team. On the plus side, it was the closest this England team under Eddie Jones has been pushed during his 14 months in charge. And, Wales are finally beginning to develop their game beyond the Warren-ball of the last too many years. I hope we can back it up by winning in Scotland in two weeks’ time.
France v Scotland
This was another close fought match, with France sneaking it 22-16. Scotland had their chances, and they are a much improved side. They have so many good back-line players that they look dangerous from anywhere on the field, and it is great to see them so competitive again. They are going to be a tough prospect for Wales in what is our next game.
Round 3 of the 6 Nations
The 6 Nations now takes a slight hiatus; the next round of matches are in a fortnight’s time rather than this coming weekend. On Saturday 25th February, Wales head up to Murrayfield to take on Scotland, with the KO at 14:25. The second match of the day is Ireland at home to France, KO is 16:50. On Sunday 26th, England host Italy at Twickenham, with the KO at 15:00. I will preview these matches closer to the time.
Read Full Post »